49ers' John Lynch: Jimmy Garoppolo to Remain with SF Despite Plans to Draft QB


49ers' John Lynch: Jimmy Garoppolo to Remain with SF Despite Plans to Draft QB
Scott Eklund/Associated Press

When the San Francisco 49ers made a huge trade to move up to No. 3 in this year's NFL draft, the prevailing belief was that the team did so to select a quarterback. That put Jimmy Garoppolo's future in San Francisco in question. 

But both general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan told reporters Monday that the plan is to draft a young quarterback and to keep Garoppolo:

Albert Breer @AlbertBreer

49ers GM John Lynch: "We felt like we had a team that can compete. ... We went to ownership, said 'hey things are looking good, we want to make this (trade), but we don't want to say good bye to Jimmy.'" Ownership signed off on keeping both a rookie and Jimmy Garoppolo.

Nick Wagoner @nwagoner

#49ers coach Kyle Shanahan said it's accurate that team is planning to keep Jimmy Garoppolo, barring being blown away by offer. Shanahan said he believes it would be hard to find a QB who helps them win right now more than Garoppolo and excited to have a QB learning behind him.

Albert Breer @AlbertBreer

49ers coach Kyle Shanahan asked on going to Alabama Pro Day tomorrow, and not North Dakota State or BYU, says it was important for the team not to tip its hand before the trade was done. "Now that you're up at 3, you don't have to hide as much."

The Niners might be telling the truth when they say they want to keep Garoppolo heading into next season. He's under contract for two more seasons, and the Niners could choose to let a young player develop behind him for the duration of that contract. 

Or the Niners are simply putting up a smoke screen, hoping to drive up the price with teams by creating the impression they want to keep Garoppolo. It's rare that a team uses a top-three pick on a young quarterback, only to keep him locked on the bench for a season or two. 

NFL players aren't devoid of ego, and trading a flurry of future draft picks to select a young quarterback isn't going to sit well with Garoppolo, who knows he's now on borrowed time in San Francisco. Likewise, a young incoming player isn't going to be thrilled by the notion of sitting a year or two behind Garoppolo. 

It has the potential to become pretty awkward, in other words. 

Matt Barrows @mattbarrows

Shanahan said he figured Jimmy Garoppolo was “a little pissed off” by the news the 49ers had traded to No. 3. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. “The more mad he gets, the better Jimmy gets,” Shanahan said.

Robert Mays @robertmays

@SandoNFL @timkawakami I understand this, in theory, and think it actually makes some sense. But $25 million feels like a very expensive public relations strategy and two 1st-round picks is A LOT to give up for someone who’s gonna spend any time on the bench behind Jimmy Garoppolo.

The Niners traded the No. 12 overall pick in the 2021 NFL draft, a 2021 third-rounder and first-round selections in both 2022 and 2023 to the Miami Dolphins to move up to No. 3. The general expectation is that Trevor Lawrence and Zach Wilson will be the first two picks of this year's draft, leaving the Niners to select between Ohio State's Justin Field, North Dakota State's Trey Lance and Alabama's Mac Jones. 

The latest buzz has the Niners targeting Jones:

Dane Brugler @dpbrugler

Time will tell if it comes to fruition, but the buzz about Mac Jones at No. 3 is undeniable. Kyle Shanahan doesn't attend many pro days. The fact that he will be at Jones' pro day tomorrow tells us the Alabama QB is a legit contender at No. 3. https://t.co/NJpRe0Fg9k

Troy Renck @TroyRenck

When I first heard the move, I thought it was for Lance. And have him redshirt this season behind Jimmy G. But people who know Kyle Shanahan a lot better believe Mac Jones is firmly in play. It is fascinating. #Denver7 https://t.co/K2uQAah6Xi

Andrew Perloff @andrewperloff

"You don't trade up nine spots for a quarterback who has things to work on. That's why I think it's Mac Jones." - @CSimmsQB on which QB 49ers will take at No. 3 on @dpshow

Peter King of ProFootballTalk reported Monday that Jones "is in the mix" for the Niners, though he added that there is a "cadre of evaluators who do not think Jones is a great quarterback for 2021 football because he's not mobile like a Lance or Wilson."

And a player like Lance might not be as plug-and-play as Jones, but he could have enough enticing long-term potential—and a higher ceiling than a Jones or Fields—that the Niners would be comfortable moving serious draft assets to acquire him, even if it means grooming him for a year or two behind Garoppolo. 

So there's a lot of moving pieces in play. One thing is certain—San Francisco is going to draft a quarterback at No. 3. What remains less certain is what that means for Garoppolo.